• Fri, May 23 - 8:54 am ET

Miley Cyrus Reportedly Calls J.Law A Liar, Which I Think Breaks One Of The Ten Commandments

Miley Cyrus black and white

When Jennifer Lawrence went on Late Night With Seth Meyers and told a story about drunkenly puking in front of a judgmental Miley Cyrus at Madonna’s Oscar party, it seemed like a funny talk show story we wouldn’t be talking about for very long. But according to this alleged tweet from Miley Cyrus, this ain’t over. Why? Because the tweet claims those events never happened. Would Miley Cyrus dare question the universe’s dream BFF? Who should we even believe? How soon should I grab the popcorn?

Oh No They Didn’t! has a screenshot of a tweet allegedly sent and then deleted by Miley in response to the interview:

Miley Cyrus Jennifer Lawrence tweet lying May 2014

Uh oh. Shit just got real. If Miley did actually send that tweet, why would she delete it so quickly? Maybe she read the comments on our recent post daring to criticize J.Law and realized that it’s simply not allowed. But who should we even trust here? Should we trust J.Law, who was admittedly drunk to the point of puking at the time and might not even remember what happened? (Gawker wonders if she purposely exaggerated the events to sound cooler, kind of like she’s been accused of faking her red carpet falls.) Or should we trust Miley, who also dabbles in mind-altering substances and tells her own “Look how cool I am!” stories.

But could this all have just been a misunderstanding that J.Law twisted into an anecdote? She never made it entirely clear whether Miley told her to “get it together” verbally, or just gave her a look that suggested it. Some people seem to have taken her vagueness and assumed Miley specifically said it, but it could have been that a drunk J.Law saw Miley standing nearby, assumed she was being judged, and figured it would make a fun late night story without considering what would happen if Miley found out. And can we really be surprised by that when she’s been praised time and time again for her “realness” and lack of filter? She’s got a reputation to live up to, but unfortunately that comes with the risk of annoying and/or offending people.

(GIF: Tumblr)

You can reach this post's author, Jill O’Rourke, on twitter.
Share This Post:
  • dan

    If you watch the video it’s clear that Jennifer didn’t mean that Miley TOLD her to get it together. It’s clear she meant that her expression was like that. Also I’m going to believe the one who said it on national television, so Jennifer. Why would she bring Miley’s name into it if it wasn’t true?

    • Jill O’Rourke

      I agree she seemed to be saying it was just a look that suggested it, but it is being reported on in some places as if Miley SAID it to her. I also think it’s possible they’re both telling the truth and Jennifer just interpreted it as Miley judging her.

    • JenH1986

      I’m thinking the latter. Jennifer realized she was a sloppy mess. Miley was there and Miley is looking all pissy (she has BRF, I have it too so no judgment) and Jennifer was all “Shit, get it together.”

    • Gloria

      Jennifer has no reason to lie especially if she herself is telling everyone she was wasted. Why make the stuff up about Miley. I wouldn’t put it past Miley to say it she is like that.

  • Natalie

    I believe Jennifer tbh. Even if it IS an exaggerated story, who the f cares? Do people really believe that the stories being told in talk shows are all true? Also why is everyone putting JLaw under a microscope all of a sudden? Is everyone really that desperate to find something so we can all attack her together? JFC let the girl be.

    • victoria

      Yeah I have noticed that too. It’s kind of sad really. But that’s what we do best. We build them up just to bring them down.

    • cecilyst

      Miley Cyrus is controlled by egomaniac fashion designer Marc Jacobs. He is responsible for her shocking new image. Read more at styleangelique blogspot

  • victoria

    Hm I really can’t see Jennifer lying about this. If the story wasn’t true she could have said that a random person gave her that look. But she names Miley specifically so i believe that’s true. Maybe Miley didn’t recognize it was Jennifer? Maybe Jennifer thought that Miley was looking at her but in fact she wasn’t Who knows.

    • gie

      CAN ANYBODY BLAME MILEY CYRUS? FOR TELLING THE TRUTH, WHEN MOST OF THE TIME MILEY CYRUS WILL TELL THE TRUTH TO YOUR FACE KIND OF GIRL,SHE’S NOT A GOOD ACTRESS YOU KNOW AND MOST PROBABLY MILEY CYRUS WAS VERY SOBER THAT NIGHT COMPARED TO JENNIFER LAURENCE GOT VERY WASTED THAT NIGHT BY HER QWN ADMITION AND MOST THE WHEN YOUR WASTED YOU DON’T REALLY REMEMBER WHAT HAPPEN( I HAVE BROTHERS YOU KNOW), BESIDES WE NEVER HEARD THAT PUKING STORY FROM THE MOUTH OF MILEY CYRUS EVER. AND MILEY CYRUS HATE LIES MOST THE TIME. SHE SURELY WILL CALLED YOU TO YOUR LIES. IF MILEY CYRUS ERASED THE TWITTER TO THE PUKING STORY PROBABLYMILEY CYRUS REALIZED BY HER OWN ADMITION TO THE TRUTH WILL CAUGHT JENNIFER LAURENCE LIES? MY, THIS IS A GOOD AND SOBERING LESSONS TO EVERYBODY. JUST DON’T ATTEMP TO TELL ANY STORY WHEN YOUR SO WASTED.

    • Nbl

      Didn’t Miley tell her audience at a concert recently that she wrote Wreaking Ball, even though she definitely did not?

    • Gloria

      Miley lies if it gets her attention.

    • Gloria

      Do you have to yell? Type caps off. Miley lies who the hell you kidding. Miley often starts trouble for the hell of it. Geez unreal. So what if Jennifer was drunk and she interpreted a look from Miley. I can really see Miley acting that way as she is full of herself. Thinks the world revolves around her.

  • Emily

    Jennifer is a proven liar and a fake. When will people wake up and realize that she is not genuine? I think she should just give canned answers, no one thinks she’s funny or cute. Better yet is she aware that the world collectively hates her now? If she doesn’t know it by now she’s in for a rude shock.

    • Woah

      First, I just want to know where you get saying Jennifer is a proven liar, I don’t recall reading much about her getting caught in a lies. Second, why should she go Hollywood and give canned answers, candor is what everyone wants from celebs and Jennifer gives it but now get knocked for it. Third, she still has tons of fans and the same group of internet haters. I don’t think Jennifer is all that worried about, most of her fans will still be her fans. Wow you have a lot of hate for someone you have never met.

    • Emily

      All of her lies and disgusting behaviour are well documented on this site, just look at the archives. It is so appalling that we are not allowed to criticsize her. And her so called fans are delusional thinking she has ever contributed anything positive to warrant any of the overblown respect she has.

    • Woah

      I know nothing about the lying if its true or not so I’m moving on from that one. But to your second point. You can criticize her all you want but her fans have every right to counter back and praise her. That is how an argument works. You saying that her fans are delusional allows them to say your delusional to, it goes both ways.

    • Emily

      Fair enough I apologize to the fans that aren’t irrational. But those who endlessly praise Jennifer need to quit it. She needs a hard dose of reality that the public generally doesn’t like her and wants her to go away.

    • Gloria

      personally I think your just jealous of her. haven’t seen her lie once and if you believe everything written in any mag or website your crazy

  • Haley Keller

    I took Jennifer as saying that Miley just gave her a look that Jennifer interpreted a certain way. I think it’s entirely possible that they’re both telling the truth. Jennifer probably really thought that Miley was thinking that because she (Jennifer) was feeling a bit self-conscious about it or something, but Miley didn’t really mean the look that way. I’m pretty sure it’s just a case of each girl having a different view of what happened.

    • Jill O’Rourke

      Yeah, that seems to be the most likely explanation.

  • Woah

    Here is the problem with making an article out of a screen grab that some supposed fan had of a Miley tweet. Miley might have wrote it but deleted it in under a minute which shows her immaturity knowing what it would cause or she might not have wrote it all and the fan made the fake screen grab as it is very easy to do. But all the sudden their is a controversy over nothing. I’m not a fangirl or Jennifers but I am sure she did not lie on national TV, people can’t comprehend – she was saying Miley gave her the WTF look so she needed to get it together. More drama about nothing.

  • Melanie

    it would be nice to know the age of the posters on comment boards

  • Alyssa

    She was probably high when it happened.