The Tammy Trailer Proves Even Melissa McCarthy Typecasts Melissa McCarthy

Melissa McCarthy Tammy trailer 2014 2

I love Melissa McCarthy. I think she’s an incredibly talented and fearless performer, which is why it disappoints me that she can’t stop playing the same character over and over again. It’s especially disappointing that in this teaser trailer for her new movie Tammy, which comes out July 2, she’s even typecast herself. The movie’s about a woman who loses her job and finds out her husband has been cheating on her, so she takes a road-trip with her grandmother (Susan Sarandon). Melissa co-wrote the movie with her husband Ben Falcone, who directed it, but it seems even Melissa McCarthy can’t write a different role for Melissa McCarthy.

The trailer features a scene in which the title character robs a fast food restaurant. As usual, she’s unkempt and unfashionable, but she’s dancing away like she doesn’t even know how bad she looks. And she can’t jump over the counter because hahaha she’s fat, you guys! We’ve never noticed that before. Oh right, except in Bridesmaids and Identity Thief and in half her SNL characters. So much of Melissa’s humor in these roles is derived from her weight, because isn’t it so funny that an overweight woman would be so confident about herself? That’s just hilarious!

I don’t mean to imply that Melissa has never played a different character, because she most certainly has, and she was so good at it that I want her to do it more. Her character Sookie St. James on Gilmore Girls was lovable and funny in a much more understated way, and I don’t recall a single reference to her size in the series’ seven-season run. But she can also be more over-the-top without participating in a string of fat jokes, and I think The Heat is proof of that. Her character wasn’t glamorous, but her humor came from more than just her appearance. Her interactions with Sandra Bullock were gold, she had hilarious one-liners, and she gave the character an emotional complexity. I think her Oscar nomination should have come from that movie and not Bridesmaids.

What makes Tammy especially disheartening is that Melissa wrote it herself with the person who arguably knows her best — her husband. The message this trailer sends, while obviously only representing one minute and forty seconds of a much longer film, is that Melissa thinks of herself the same way the creators of something like Identity Thief think of her. She’s so much more talented than that, and I’d have hoped a character of her creation would have shown that instead of just recycling the stuff she’s already done.

(GIF: Tumblr)

You can reach this post's author, Jill O’Rourke, on twitter.
Share This Post:
    • Alexis Rhiannon

      You know what also didn’t look great, though, is The Heat. So maybe it’s a trick of the trailer? I hope so.

      • Jenni


      • Jill O’Rourke

        This is true. Fingers crossed.

    • Josie

      This is a good article, Jill. I totally agree with you.

      • Jill O’Rourke

        Thanks for reading!

    • Paige

      Thank you for articulating what I’ve been thinking/feeling for at least a year. McCarthy has played the identical role at least four times, Bridesmaids, Identity Thief, The Heat, and now her own penned mess, Tammy. I initially thought she was incredibly talented, but she’s lacking range, and is becoming the new Chris Farley, Will Ferrell, and Adam Sandler. Too bad. There was a real opportunity for her to break type.

    • Pingback: Melissa McCarthy Would Love It If You'd Stop Referring To Her Weight As A Handicap - Crushable()

    • Pingback: Melissa McCarthy Talks About Susan Sarandon On Tammy Set()

    • Elizabeth Aspen

      You’re freaking out over nothing. Louie Anderson built his career on his own brand of self-deprecating humor about his weight and it was always funny. If this makes Melissa comfortable, then why is there a bug up your ass about it? It would take someone who is very confident about her body to do that in the first place.

      And sorry, but fat people not being able to climb over a counter? Funny. And I say this as a fat chick myself.

      • Alexis Rhiannon

        I don’t know that I’m freaking out, just voicing part of why I didn’t care for the movie. And you and I have different feelings about the counter scene.