• Thu, Oct 24 - 2:42 pm ET

Modern Family Ripped Off Seinfeld Last Night And The Internet Called Them Out

Modern Family Cam and Mitch

I’ll admit that I haven’t been keeping up with the new episodes of Modern Family as well as I used to. I don’t know if it’s because I think that I’m too busy (I’m not), if the show isn’t as good as it once was, or if Parenthood is better, but it just hasn’t been grabbing my attention as of late. That is, until HuffPo noticed that the internet was aflutter with tweets wondering why the show decided to tear a storyline from Seinfeld and not even try to hide it. Then, of course, I was all ears.

The episode in question is last night’s episode, The Help, which was about Mitch and Cam trying to hide the fact that they went behind the back of their wedding planner and friend, Pepper, because they like the way that his assistant, Ronaldo, plans nuptials. Since they know that Pepper, who’s known for his hysterics, will overreact, they spend the episode doing everything that they can to keep him from finding out. Now, if you’ll take a time machine with me back to 1993 when Seinfeld’s The Barber episode aired, that’d be awesome. Please don’t touch anything, as you might cause a Butterfly Effect that will result in you not being born, which would be less than ideal, to say the least. Anyway, Jerry experiences that exact situation, except with his regular barber and his barber’s nephew. Same exact.

You could probably have an argument that lots of people pay homage to earlier works, which is true and could have been the case here. After all, Seinfeld is a huge part of TV history. And there’s also the possibility that it was genuinely a coincidence and that no one over at Modern Family realized the similarities. Those are both things that you could argue, but then the little devil on my other shoulder will just tell me to not listen to you because the two episodes just feel so similar. It’s just so hard for me to believe that the Mod Fam writers just happened to think up the “person feels like they’re cheating on the person they hired because they liked someone else’s work better” storyline without one person thinking, “wait, where have I seen this before?”

And, while I doubt that Jerry Seinfeld and the Seinfeld writers will take a break from rolling in their mountains of cash to care all that much, I think it ends up coming off as a little desperate on the part of Modern Family. If they’re going to boast that they’re pushing TV boundaries and being innovative all day long, then maybe put their money where their mouths are and take note of ideas that are so dangerously close to episode ideas from 20 years ago. Seriously, guys, what’s the deal with that? *Ba dum tss*

(Photo: ABC via IMDb)

You can reach this post's author, Olivia Wilson, on twitter.
What We're Reading:
Share This Post:
  • Jill O’Rourke

    Now all I wanna do is watch Seinfeld.

    • Olivia Wilson

      Good thing that’s the only show that TBS knows how to air!

    • CMc

      Lol. That and Big Bang Theory.

  • Pingback: Small Screen Snob | Modern Family’s still a hit

  • Scott Johnson

    Give me a break. There are no original sitcom ideas left.

    • Olivia Wilson

      I beg to differ!

  • CrazyLogic

    On one hand, boo ripping off. On the other hand, I wouldn’t be surprised if this was a complete accident. I mean…with all the media and stories in the world, “it’s been done” happens a lot when it comes to writing anything…

    Or it could be something I sometimes do and they got it from the show without realizing it. I did that with a Rugrats episode and a short story once…the episode aired when I was four.

    • Olivia Wilson

      That’s true, they’re all possibilities. I’m just hoping, for creativity’s sake, that it was coincidental!

    • CrazyLogic

      Two sit coms that I am told did everything. Simpsons and Sienfield. Hell, even the Bible says there’s nothing new under the sun…

      And there is this TV Tropes page!

      http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ItsBeenDone

  • Nikki

    Yeah, I’m gonna beg for a break to be given here. I think this is a complete coincidence. The reason it seems so similar is because things like this happen in real life. Maybe not that specific, but nonetheless. We want someone else to do something for us because we think they do it better, but we don’t want to hurt the first person’s feelings. That is something that completely reflects real life. For me, at least.

  • Peter

    What a dumb article! I am sure Seinfeld was not the first to have this rather simple concept written into an episode.

  • Pingback: Jerry Seinfeld Accuses The LEGO Movie Of Stealing His Jokes