• Wed, Jan 23 2013

I Really Do Want To Like The Mindy Project More Than I Do

Mindy Project Cast

I went into the first season of The Mindy Project with incredibly high hopes. I loved Mindy Kaling on The Office and I loved her even more after reading her debut book, Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me (And Other Concerns). Therefore I expected her first show to be an awesome comedy that not only made me laugh, but also made smart points that are relevant to my life. You know, a show where I’m like “it’s funny because it’s true.” While I never felt like Kelly Kapoor delivered that feeling for me on the The Office, I definitely felt like Mindy did in her book. And since Mindy was the the woman behind this show (and in front of this show), I thought she would be able to deliver.

However we’re now halfway through the first season of The Mindy Project and I just don’t like it as much as I want to like it. Don’t get me wrong. It’s a funny show that’s makes me to laugh aloud. But not often. Certainly not often enough that I rush home to watch each week. Like many other shows that I record out of habit, it lingers on my DVR until I get through all my must-see TV for the week. But that’s not the way it’s supposed to be. It’s a comedy about a woman made by a funny woman. How did this happen?

While watching the past few episodes I’ve tried to figure out the problem. Diagnose it like I’m some kind of WebMd Symptom Checker for TV shows. And I think that maybe I figured it out. It’s too predictable, like it came from a comedy cookie cutter mold of TV shows past and it’s just being altered here and there for the purposes of the show.

Take Mindy and Danny’s (Chris Messina) relationship for example. Sure it’s incredibly tense now, but we know they’re going to inevitably get together. It’s like Ross and Rachel all over again — except Danny’s really mean to Mindy and that makes it somewhat hard to root for him as her love interest. It’s not so much that there’s sexual tension between the two, but rather, actual tension. We got a fat joke from him in the very first episode.

However, even with that said, if we know that they’re eventually going to end up dating, it makes all their other dates and relationships pointless. Something to get through until she and Danny realize that they’re destined to be together. We’re constantly reminded that we’re watching a comedy where something zany’s going to happen because it has to happen to end the relationship. Whether that’s Allison Williams showing up in an eye patch or Mindy trying to have casual sex with Mark Duplass, we know that these relationships won’t amount to anything.

What We're Reading:
Share This Post:
  • Alexis Rhiannon

    SAME. I feel so guilty about it but I can’t help it! There’s something missing and I can’t figure out what it is! I want to love it and I almost do.

  • Arielle

    Ditto… She’s a great writer and that comes across at parts in the show, but overall it feels way too formulaic clumsy gal comedy. But I’m just guessing a lot of that’s the influence of the network

  • Tessa

    Parks and Recreation got cancelled!?? what is this blasphemy

    • Jenni

      This year is the final year!

    • http://twitter.com/gurlcode Jenn

      No, it wasn’t cancelled. It’s listed as a “safe bet” for renewal.

    • Jenni

      I stand corrected. Last I heard it was done this season. I can ease up a little on my mourning then.

  • Hello

    parks and rec is far from cancelled. it was nbc’s second highest rated comedy last week. just after Go On

  • Eileen

    I’m so glad there are other people out there who feel the same way I do about this show! I like it. I enjoy it. But I expected to like it so much more than I do. I expecting something more like the first three seasons of 30 Rock, only probably better because I kind of think I identify with Mindy Kaling more than Tina Fey. I realize that those are unrealistic expectations. If I hadn’t expected this show to be so, so great, I’d be perfectly happy. But it has so much more potential!

  • Danny Castellano

    Why does everyone give me a hard time about telling Mindy to lose 15 pounds, but she’s within her right to make light of my being divorced? That’s backwards.