Dear Sam Claflin Detractors: Remember When Everyone Hated Josh Hutcherson As Peeta?

Josh Hutcherson cast Peeta reactions Sam Claflin Finnick OdairYesterday’s huge Catching Fire casting news of Sam Claflin taking the part of Finnick Odair seemed to either be welcomed or rejected by the Hunger Games fandom. For the detractors, it seems to be a mix of wanting someone else to get the role, or simply being unable to envision Sam as Finnick. Honestly, it sounds exactly like when Josh Hutcherson was cast a year or so ago.

Once the movie came out in March, Josh was the one who most blew us away with his sensitivity, realism, and just a dash of humor to keep things light in the Arena. Any doubts I might’ve had were erased. But let’s time travel back and just look at these comments from the official EW announcement in April 2011:

Josh Hutcherson cast Peeta reactions Sam Claflin Finnick Odair

That same disgusted/horrified knee-jerk reaction popped up on fansites and all over the web. I’ve had trouble tracking down specific editorials decrying Josh, probably because a lot of bloggers figured they’d suspend total judgment until The Hunger Games actually came out. But suffice to say, Josh did not have a lot of supporters in the early days despite being fantastic in The Kids Are All Right the prior summer. Mostly it was his looks: The brunette just didn’t match the blonde hero we’d all envisioned, especially in comparison to other candidates like Hunter Parrish.

But then it all came together! Director Gary Ross reportedly said of Josh’s audition,

“I knew when Josh walked through the door that this was the right guy. It was like the movie came to life.”

I say “reportedly” because I’ve only found it on one Tumblr. Then there’s Josh himself, who humbly thanked the fans for helping him win a role he had genuinely fought for:

“They mean the world to me. Without the fans, I wouldn’t have a job. When people hire you for a movie, they want to hire you because you’re going to bring an audience to their film. If I didn’t have people out there who enjoyed watching me as an actor, I wouldn’t get hired. Nobody would want to see the movie!”

And now I can’t find many people who still think Josh has done a bad job as Peeta! When the first trailer came out last year, the “Josh is Peeta” tag appeared on Tumblr, with users admitting that they’d been wrong. (They call themselves DANAs, which I assume is some nickname pertaining to not thinking he was right for the part.)

All it takes is time to accept the casting, and an open mind to see what the actor brings to the project. Sure, in another universe maybe your dream actor’s schedule could have opened up and he would have brought a different take to Finnick. But shouldn’t we trust the producers’ track record in bringing on Jennifer Lawrence, Lenny Kravitz, and other hotly contested castings?

Photo: Entertainment Weekly

Share This Post:
    • AudreyHuntington89

      Totally agree with you. Josh completely blew me away and brought Peeta to a whole new level. I liked the Peeta character in the books but I walked out of the movie ADORING Peeta. I have total confidence in Sam pulling off the Finnick character. We will all be amazed, I am sure.

    • lover

      i loved josh as peeta

    • Pingback: Sam Claflin | NewsTrendr()

    • Sarah

      Well, I have always loved Josh and was so excited when he got the role. I knew from seeing his other work that he would be perfect. Now I’m in the same boat with Sam. No one loves him too much, but I’m honestly psyched. I think he’ll do a great job and he is SO cute!! <– very important for Finnick ;)

    • Lee

      The quote from Tumblr is correct. It was in the making of DVD / BluRay for the Hunger Games. Gary Ross did say that himself.

    • Pingback: Dear Sam Claflin Detractors: Remember When Everyone Hated Josh … | Hunger Games()

    • Moomster77

      well that is odd because I still dont like Josh as Peeta……. and I think Sam isnt hot enough to be finnick

    • Amber

      I have loved (and always have) all the actors chosen and I think Sam will be no different. Sam is so sweet is real life (and you can’t deny he’s good-looking!) and he was so nervous about getting the role of Finnick right that I’m positive he’ll do amazing! Although he may not look exactly like I pictured Finnick, he bares quite a close resemblance. Considering Finnick is my favorite character, I’m really looking forward to how Sam will do. All the actors and actresses are amazing and I can’t wait for the film :)