• Thu, Sep 1 2011

‘That Girl in Pink’ Benni Cinkle’s Music Video ‘Can You See Me Now’ Would’ve Made a Better Second Single for Rebecca Black

Even though she and Rebecca Black aren’t friends anymore, Benni Cinkle is promoting herself as That Girl in Pink — though we’ll always remember her as “my friend is by my right, yeahh.” As promised, here’s Benni’s first single about misfits rising up against their abusers, “Can You See Me Now.” She’s emphasized that she didn’t produce it with Ark Factory, but maybe she could’ve used their help, ’cause it is just not working.

The problem is that this doesn’t work as a first single: She’s acting like we know and trust her enough to take this politically-charged message. Really, it would’ve been ideal for Rebecca.

We admit it, we were curiously looking forward to Rebecca’s second single, “My Moment,” which made it even more of a letdown. It was a lame “yay I’m famous” piece of fluff, and Kelly Clarkson‘s “A Moment Like This” already rules that roost. It was instantly forgettable.

But a big part of Rebecca’s journey that we’ve seen so far is how many people utterly hate her. She had to drop out of school because of bullying, after her video became a viral sensation and cruel teenagers had plenty of ammunition to throw at her. A “rise up and fight” song like “Can You See Me Now” would have been the perfect retort for Rebecca. I’m not saying that the song is any better in quality than “My Moment,” but at least the subject matter fits better.

Ah, well. Benni has a website devoted to her pink persona, so you can keep up with her inevitable next single. One question, though: Why does she look like a middle-aged housewife? There’s some weird combination of the lights and the wind machine to make her look way older, and not in a good way. She can’t be more than fourteen, right?

[via]

Share This Post:
  • Kasey

    I really love this song and the message! Benni’s just a kid and it’s great to see her take the Friday-fame/hate in stride and make something beautiful out of the backlash. Other teens will relate to this song and be able to have a positive role model.

    I don’t think it matters that her first single was “a stand up and fight song,” it fits her prefectly for who she is! Benni really cares about others and would rather use her fifteen minutes of fame to promote good causes rather than talk about herself.

  • Lisa Rupp

    As an adult this song isn’t something I would listen to on the radio, but when coupled with the video I think it’s truly something spectacular.

    It’s well made, catchy and the messages are so inspiring. Benni is a great role model for young girls!! Think about it this way: kids who know about the Rebecca Black video are being exposed to so much negativity online. Even if they didn’t participate in the RB-bashing they probably read those comments or watched the cruel parody videos. Isn’t it time our kids were exposed to videos with a more positive message? I think it’s great that something as good as Benni Cinkle could come from the Friday debacle.

    She’s really stepping up and doing her part to help others! If you check out her website she even started a charity to help teens deal with all sorts of issues like dating abuse, pregnancy or self-harming in a nonjudgemental environment. Whether she succeeds in the music industry or not, Benni Cinkle is an inspiring person and a force to be reckoned with!

  • Jessalyn

    I see where you’re coming from about this suiting Rebecca better as a followup single because RB had to face so much hate. (BUT WAIT: how did she drop out of school over the SUMMER?? riddle me this…) ;)

    But I think this song is much more perfect for Benni. It’s who she is: she doesn’t have a big plan to break into the music industry; a list of the order of songs she needs to release to be famous. Benni’s a kid who happened to find herself thrown into the limelight and this was a song that SHE wrote and decided to record because it’s a true representation of who SHE is.

    • Todd77

      WHOA! you’re right about the school, by the way! it totally was summer when she announced that…

      I like this song too. Benni is just a positive “stand up and take charge” person so it’s only fitting that that is her first song. It’s representative of who Benni wants to be in the music industry: if something bigger does come of her Friday fame, Benni just wants to use her influence to help others

  • clarissa rosee

    BENNI! this song is great for young girls like me. the lyrics are so much better knowing she wrote them herself and for a good cause

  • Courtney Simpson

    I love Benni Cinkle’s song. It has really made me feel better about our young generation. She’s not like the other pop stars, she’s a little dorky and honesty and friendly. You don’t see that very often anymore. It’s great.