Casting ‘Babysitters Club: The Movie’

Mary Anne Spier – Emma Roberts

According to Wikipedia, “Mary Anne is the BSC secretary due to her exceptional organization skills and neat handwriting.” Barring any legibility issues plaguing Emma, we’d cast Julia’s niece in the nerdy-but-nice role.

Share This Post:
    • Alana

      I say Sue (from The Middle) has a role somewhere, she is total geek which is always how I envisioned Mallory. Girl above is too good looking!

    • hazelk

      The Baby-Sitters Club (1995) was a hit on the big screen (not a TV movie) and starred such names as Rachel Leigh Cook, Larisa Oleynik, and even Academy Award winner Ellen Burstyn.

    • Blair

      The Baby Sitters Club was actually made into a feature length film in 1995 and was distributed in theaters. Rachel Leigh Cook and Larisa Oleynik were in it: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0112435/

      I’m not sure if BSC appeals to the Gossip Girl generation but, I’d go see it.

    • becky

      what about jesse?

    • pinky

      WTF ……@@@@###&&&**!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!??????????????????????????? IS THE THING

    • BSCforlife.

      this cast is terribly inaccurate.
      emma watson is the exact opposite of tomboy kristy.
      taylor momsen is the exact opposite of hippie/organic dawn.
      mia wasikowska is anything but the ditsy shopaholic-type that stacey is.
      sarah hyland looks nothing like mallory.
      and you completely left jessi off the list.